| 1922 | Albert C. Stack* | 1957 | Albert C. Stack, Jr.* | 1987 | Robert F. Butler |
| 1923 | Harry A. Beck * | 1958 | Whitney H. Myers | 1988 | William E. Hand |
| 1923 | William S. Martin +* | 1959 | George F. McCann * | 1989 | Edwin W. Griffiths, Jr. |
| 1924 | Arthur Scrimshaw * | 1960 | Harold T. Wolf * | 1990 | Donald C. Lever, PSGS |
| 1925 | Benjamin Forrest * | 1961 | John P. Steffan * | 1991 | Stewart D. Walsh |
| 1926 | Elmer F. Giffin * | 1962 | Harold H. Croom * | 1991 | Ralph S. Hill, Jr. + |
| 1927 | Charles B. Giffin * | 1963 | Charles F. Yost | 1992 | George W. Stott, Jr. |
| 1928 | John T. Reif * | 1964 | Charles W. Engler, Jr. * | 1992 | Harry H. Wible + |
| 1929 | Charles V. Osborne, Sr.* | 1965 | Daniel A. Mullen, III * | 1993 | Dale A. Lynch, Jr., PGC |
| 1930 | Samuel G. Garrison, Jr. * | 1965 | Carl H. Gamp + * | 1994 | Henry J. Rahn, Jr. |
| 1931 | Charles P. Mills + * | 1966 | Albert L. Hann , PJGD | 1994 | Charles A. Castley, PDDGM + |
| 1932 | William R. Cannon * | 1967 | Henry Baumert * | 1995 | Russell B. Hoyle, Sr. |
| 1933 | Noah C. Bender * | 1968 | Robert E. Walsh, Jr. * | 1996 | Frazier R. Alburger |
| 1934 | F. Maurice Goodwin * | 1969 | George E. Carpenter * | 1997 | Raymond B. Kingett |
| 1935 | Michael Balent, Jr. * | 1970 | Henry Sannipoli, PDDGM * | 1997 | Jerry R. Barnish + |
| 1936 | Enos J. Jarvis * | 1971 | Leonard O. Beebe | 1998 | Kirk D. Nevius, Jr., PGC |
| 1937 | Robert F. Ranken * | 1972 | Robert D. Rowand | 1999 | Scott D. Cianci |
| 1938 | John H. Fisher, Sr. * | 1973 | Louis W. Bradley, PGT | 1999 | Frank M. Blizard, III + |
| 1939 | Oscar M. Hansen * | 1974 | Robert W. Bates, PSGD | 2000 | Paul E. Burkhardt |
| 1940 | Albert F. Neidinger,PGP * | 1975 | Frederick W. Knox | 2001 | Robert F. DiOrio |
| 1941 | Lawrence E. Gardiner* | 1976 | Leroy See * | 2001 | Donald. L. Sharp Sr. + |
| 1942 | B. Franklin Cope * | 1976 | John J. Eitel +* | 2002 | Leonard M. March, DRI |
| 1943 | Fred Humphrey * | 1977 | Roy F. Gutshall, Jr. * | 2002 | Craig J. Woodruff + |
| 1944 | Charles S. Schenick * | 1978 | John R. Beetle | 2003 | Eugene J. Applegate |
| 1945 | Ora L. Wooster, Sr. * | 1979 | Charles W. Bell | 2004 | Eugene O. Bathurst |
| 1946 | Carl C. Caldwell * | 1980 | Benjamin H. Read, Jr. | 2004 | Peter F. White + |
| 1947 | Benjamin A. Glatz * | 1981 | Joseph H. Rival, Jr., DGM | 2005 | Juan A. Caraballo, Jr |
| 1948 | Joseph H. Matthews * | 1982 | Warren E. Rival, PGC | 2006 | Moses R. Hayes, Jr. |
| 1949 | Ralph E. Husted * | 1982 | Ronald A. Rocco + | 2007 | Richard J. McCunney, II |
| 1950 | Thomas Milne * | 1983 | Hugh C. Williams | 2008 | James E. Miller, PGC + |
| 1951 | Ferdinand Herbst * | 1983 | Charles E. Oppido, Jr. +* | 2008 | Michael E. Owsiak |
| 1952 | Charles Mannice * | 1984 | Walter C. Knett * | 2008 | Brian S. Pollock + |
| 1953 | Robert C. Osborne, PGC * | 1984 | Larry S. Plasket, PGM, G Sec# | 2009 | Robert E. Kunze Sr. |
| 1954 | Earl B. Hallowell * | 1985 | Frank A. Applegate, Sr. | ||
| 1955 | Harry M. Ireland * | 1985 | Henry Bubacz + | ||
| 1956 | John M. Fisher, Jr.* | 1986 | Wilfred E. Wilson * |